Who says no when an app says sign in to continue?
Every app says getting ahead means saying yes. Europe's own survey shows the people who refuse to be tracked are the ones who build and run the machine.

Cover of The Smartness Trap (Omxus Press)

Art: Omxus Press
In February 2021 a father in San Francisco photographed his toddler's swollen groin, because a nurse asked for the pictures before a video consultation. Google's systems flagged the photos as abuse and closed his account. Police investigated and cleared him. Google kept the account closed.
More than a decade of email went. So did the photos of his son's first years, the contacts, and the phone number that came with the plan (Hill, 2022). He had done nothing wrong, and a police report said so. It made no difference, because police did not close the account and could not open it.
He did not die. But try to prove you exist.
Run it in your own life. Your email resets every password you have. Your phone holds the codes your bank sends. "Sign in with Google" ties the rest to the same account. Lose that one thing and you spend the next month failing to convince machines you are you.
No judge sits behind that button. In July 2019 GitHub cut developers in Iran, Syria, Crimea, Cuba and North Korea off from private repositories to comply with United States sanctions, for where they lived rather than anything they did (Lardinois, 2019). Some found months of their own work out of reach overnight. A United States court held in 2010 that the government needs a warrant to read your stored email (United States v. Warshak, 2010). The company holding it needs your click on "I agree".
Nobody voted for this. Free email in 2004, a beautiful phone in 2007, friends on Facebook in 2008: each was a good deal on the day. Between them the four companies holding most of it took about US$1.04 trillion in 2023 (Alphabet Inc., 2024; Apple Inc., 2023; Meta Platforms, 2024; Microsoft Corporation, 2023).
Your thinking is next. The capable AI most people use comes by the month, and the company decides what it answers and whether you keep access. Yet open models such as DeepSeek-R1 are among the most capable released (Guo et al., 2025), and machines that run them fit beside a desk. On rough sums of our own, one person's subscription stays cheaper for years. Shared by a few households, the machine wins, the way towns once shared a library.
So is your reach. On 4 October 2021 one configuration change took Facebook, Instagram and WhatsApp offline for about six hours (Janardhan, 2021). Families who talk only on WhatsApp sat in the same suburb unable to reach each other. Yet the Bluetooth radio in your phone can pass a message to the phone next door, and that phone to the next, with no tower between them. A standard for it has existed since 2017 (Bluetooth SIG, 2017). A mesh of phones has no single switch to flip.
All of that leaves the hardest problem. Hand identity back to people and someone will make ten thousand fake ones. Computer scientists call it a Sybil attack (Douceur, 2002). The answers on offer scan your eye, map your friendships or film your face, and each one leaves a company holding something more of you.
There is an older answer. Four times a year, at the same hour everywhere, stand in a room with three other people for an hour. Your phones confirm you were all there. Everyone signs the head count. Nobody can be in two rooms at once, so nobody counts twice, and no company holds anything. Security researchers proposed the core of it, "pseudonym parties", in 2008 (Ford & Strauss, 2008).
It sounds lovely and it sounds impossible. People won't do it.
Australia has already run that experiment. At the federal election of 1922, 59.4% of enrolled voters turned up. Parliament made voting the law, and at the next election, on Saturday 14 November 1925, 91.4% did (Australian Electoral Commission, 2023). It has not fallen below 89.8% since: not through the Depression, a world war or a pandemic.
The fine for staying home is $20 (Australian Electoral Commission, 2025). No one turns up for fear of $20. Part of that first jump came from other reforms, and turnout was already drifting up. But the same people who could not be bothered in 1922 have spent a century queueing for a sausage, because turning up is what everyone here does. Habits like this one can be built. We built one.
You would have to spend an hour with your neighbours. You would learn their names. You might borrow sugar next month.
That looks like the cost. Across 148 studies, people with stronger social relationships had about 50% greater odds of survival (Holt-Lunstad et al., 2010). Think about who would notice this week if your account vanished, and who would notice if you did. People will complain right up until they realise it is the first time in years someone checked if they were alive.
The Sybil problem is the excuse. The connection is the point.
None of this asks you to delete anything. Download your own archive: Google calls it Takeout, and Apple and Meta have the same thing under privacy settings. Keep the copy on something you can hold. Write down which accounts your email can unlock, and give the worst of them a second way in.
Then do the part no company can do for you. Learn the names of three people who live near you. Your neighbours can confirm you exist. No terms of service can take that back.
Every app says getting ahead means saying yes. Europe's own survey shows the people who refuse to be tracked are the ones who build and run the machine.

Cover of The Smartness Trap (Omxus Press)
In Estonia you can. A log shows which agency read your data and why. What it looks like, who it caught, and why Australia has nothing like it.

Photo: EU2017EE Estonian Presidency, CC BY 2.0, via Wikimedia Commons
Chattanooga's city power company built gigabit fibre in 2010. Ten years on, a study counted $2.69 billion in benefits. Catalonia and Australia tried too.

Photo: Harrison Keely, CC BY 4.0, via Wikimedia Commons