a/work· 31 October 2026 · 7 min read

What would it cost to fix the worst rule in Australian super insurance?

Art: Omxus Press

In May 2016 Wayne McDougall, a long-haul truck driver, was heading across the country to WA when a bad headache turned out to be a stroke. He'd paid for total and permanent disability cover through his super for five years. He claimed. "Now that I needed it," he told CHOICE, "I got nothing" (Herborn, 2020). His insurer had reclassified long-haul trucking as hazardous, and that put him on a different test: fail two of a list of basics, such as eating, bathing and dressing. He couldn't dress himself. He could still walk and speak. His neurologist said he was unlikely ever to work again, and under the standard definition he'd have qualified. Refused.

Man up. Then the back goes, or the head does, and you find out what your premiums bought.

Deleting that test would cost each Australian member about six dollars a year.

A catastrophe test, not a disability test

Total and permanent disability (TPD) cover sits inside most Australians' super, usually by default. It comes in two grades. The ordinary grade asks whether you can ever work again in a job suited to your education, training and experience. The other asks whether you can feed, bathe, dress, use a toilet or walk. It focuses "on the physical activity itself" and does not usually reference cognitive ability, pain, or the medication needed to keep going (Australian Securities and Investments Commission [ASIC], 2019a).

You can lose the use of an arm, have your spine fused, have a mind that no longer holds a shift together, never work again, and still dress yourself. That's a catastrophe test, not a disability test. And both grades cost the same.

Nobody picks it. The fund's rules put you on it if you work under a set number of hours (15 a week is one example), were unemployed or on unpaid leave for a set period before you fell ill, or work in a job the insurer rates as high risk. ASIC names who that catches: unskilled workers, carers, and workers in retail and hospitality (ASIC, 2019a). Members are rarely told which grade they hold. In the Productivity Commission's survey, 24% did not know whether their fund insured them at all, and a further 16% knew they paid for insurance but not what it covered (Productivity Commission, 2018, as cited in ASIC, 2019a).

Junk, said the regulator

On 17 October 2019 ASIC published Holes in the safety net, its review of 35,026 TPD claims made to seven insurers in 2016 and 2017 (ASIC, 2019a). Commissioner Sean Hughes said members on the narrow grade were "typically paying the same premium – for what is essentially junk insurance" (ASIC, 2019b).

The tables in that report tell it. Of 737 finalised claims assessed on daily living, 441 were refused: 59.8%. On the ordinary "any occupation" test, 11.9% of 22,468 were refused. A claim on the narrow grade was five times as likely to be refused, for the same premium.

Kind of claimRefused on "daily living"Refused on the ordinary test
Mental illness77%15%
Musculoskeletal disorders71%13%
Injury or fracture60%15%
Disease41%9%
All claims59.8%11.9%

(ASIC, 2019a, Tables 8 and 17.)

The conditions that most often end a manual worker's career are the ones the test refuses most. ASIC's conclusion is blunt: the high declined rate "appears mainly to be caused by eligibility criteria", because consumers with injuries unsuited to the narrow definition "are forced to rely on it by the terms of their cover". Four per cent of TPD claims went through the test, so ASIC counted "at least 4% of the 12 million consumers (480,000) who hold TPD in superannuation" as "potentially at risk of unusable or inadequate cover" (ASIC, 2019a, paras 90–91). Behind each of those 480,000 is a person who paid every year for cover they may never have known they held.

Then something good happened, and stopped

Four years later ASIC checked again. Of 15 trustees, two had removed the daily-living definition completely, nine had replaced it, and one was replacing it, with an "activities of daily working" test, which ASIC still calls restrictive. Nine had lengthened the unemployment period before the test applies and nine had dropped hours-of-work or casual-employment criteria (ASIC, 2023, p. 12).

Claims assessed on daily living fell to 232 in 2021–22, 1.3% of TPD claims. Of those, 52% were declined, against 8% under "any occupation" (ASIC, 2023, Tables 8–9).

That's progress, and it came from a regulator publishing a number and a few consumer advocates refusing to drop it. It's also where the progress stopped. As the ordinary refusal rate fell, the daily-living rate didn't follow, and the gap between them widened from about three times to about six and a half between 2015–16 and 2021–22 (Australian Prudential Regulation Authority [APRA], 2026a). Twelve of the fifteen trustees kept a restrictive definition of some kind (ASIC, 2023, p. 12). And changes usually only help people injured after them. An old rule keeps working on old claims.

The price of deleting it

Cost = daily-living claims a year × (their refusal rate − the ordinary refusal rate) × the average benefit paid. Spread it over everyone who holds the cover.

  • ASIC counted "almost three TPD claims a day" under daily living (ASIC, 2019b): taken here as 1,000 a year. ASIC's own count for 2018 is 1,046 (ASIC, 2019a).
  • Refused at 60% on the narrow test and 12% on the ordinary one (ASIC, 2019a).
  • The average admitted group-super TPD claim paid $121,279 in the year to December 2018; call it $120,000 (APRA, 2026a).
  • Cost: $57.6 million a year, spread over the 9.3 million members with group cover in super (APRA counts 9.26 million with group-super death cover; APRA, 2026a).

That's $6.19 per member per year. Vary the benefit from $80,000 to $200,000 and it runs from $4.13 to $10.32. Double the lodgements and it's $12.39. If the lower 2021–22 count of 232 claims has held, it's $1.77. This assumes people refused on the narrow test would be refused at the ordinary rate once assessed on the ordinary one, and ASIC's finding that eligibility rules drive the gap supports that. Even pushed hard, the sums stay under about $20.

Who pays

Nobody new. The people who already pay.

Group lump-sum risk cover took in $6.249 billion in gross premiums in the twelve months to 31 March 2026 and paid out $5.814 billion in claims, 93.0% of premiums (APRA, 2026b). The headline $57.6 million is 0.92% of that pool. On group cover the insurers run close to break-even, so nobody needs a villain here. The harm is a paragraph of drafting, applied to the people least able to contest it. Deleting it needs no levy, no budget measure and no Commonwealth dollar. It needs the pool to price one definition instead of two, which is what members thought they were buying.

How the Dutch do it

In the Netherlands, an employer keeps paying a sick worker for two years, with legal duties on both sides to attempt a return to work. After that, the public Employee Insurance Agency, not the party who pays, decides how much earning capacity has been lost. The benefit is scaled to the loss (Koning & Lindeboom, 2015). Australia already has an external body that hears TPD disputes after the fact, the Australian Financial Complaints Authority. An independent assessor before the fact is a reallocation of work insurers now duplicate, not new spending.

What you can do

Nobody should have to find out what their cover means on the worst day of their life. Policy takes years. These take an afternoon.

  1. Find out which definition you are on. Ring your fund and say: "Is my TPD cover assessed under the any-occupation definition, or under activities of daily living or daily working? What would move me from one to the other?" If the answer is a restrictive test, decide knowingly whether to keep paying for it.
  2. Check for duplicate accounts. Every old account from every old job charges its own fees and, sometimes, its own insurance premiums (Productivity Commission, 2018).
  3. If you earn under the government co-contribution threshold, use it. For each after-tax dollar a low-income earner puts in, the government adds 50 cents, up to $500 a year (Superannuation (Government Co-contribution for Low Income Earners) Act 2003, Cth). The ATO publishes the current income limits.
  4. If a claim was refused, take it to the Australian Financial Complaints Authority. It costs a consumer nothing to lodge.
  5. Tell your fund and your federal member what you found. The 2019 report moved fifteen trustees. Numbers in public move things, and so do members who ask.

The evidence was never the problem. A regulator published it in 2019, in a report anyone can download, and again in 2023. Wayne McDougall drove trucks for most of his life and paid every premium. Six dollars.

You paid for it. Read the test before you need it.

Sources

  1. Australian Prudential Regulation Authority. (2026a). Life insurance claims and disputes statistics database, June 2018 to December 2025 [Data set]. https://www.apra.gov.au/life-insurance-claims-and-disputes-statistics
  2. Australian Prudential Regulation Authority. (2026b). Quarterly life insurance performance statistics database, September 2023 to June 2026 [Data set]. https://www.apra.gov.au/quarterly-life-insurance-performance-statistics
  3. Australian Securities and Investments Commission. (2019a). Holes in the safety net: A review of TPD insurance claims (Report 633). https://download.asic.gov.au/media/5311117/rep633-published-17-october-2019.pdf
  4. Australian Securities and Investments Commission. (2019b, October 17). ASIC calls on insurers and trustees to take action to improve consumer outcomes from total and permanent disability insurance (Media release 19-281MR). https://www.asic.gov.au/about-asic/news-centre/find-a-media-release/2019-releases/19-281mr-asic-calls-on-insurers-and-trustees-to-take-action-to-improve-consumer-outcomes-from-total-and-permanent-disability-insurance
  5. Australian Securities and Investments Commission. (2023). Insurance in superannuation: Industry progress on delivering better outcomes for members (Report 760). https://download.asic.gov.au/media/smpp02v3/rep760-published-22-march-2023.pdf
  6. Herborn, D. (2020, January 29). Junk insurance in super: 'I got nothing' says Wayne. CHOICE. choice.com.au
  7. Koning, P., & Lindeboom, M. (2015). The rise and fall of disability insurance enrollment in the Netherlands. Journal of Economic Perspectives, 29(2), 151–172. https://doi.org/10.1257/jep.29.2.151
  8. Productivity Commission. (2018). Superannuation: Assessing efficiency and competitiveness (Inquiry Report No. 91). Commonwealth of Australia. https://www.pc.gov.au/inquiries-and-research/superannuation/assessment/report

Keep reading