a/internet· 31 October 2026 · 5 min read

Who says no when an app says sign in to continue?

Cover of The Smartness Trap (Omxus Press)

On 21 June 2016 Mark Zuckerberg posted a cheerful photo to celebrate 500 million Instagram users. A Twitter user named Chris Olson looked past the grin to the laptop on the desk behind him. There was tape over its camera, and tape over the microphone jack (CNBC, 2016). The man who built the world's biggest sign-in button had covered the lens with sticky tape.

Become smart, or else

We're told the opposite story. Two scholars, Orit Halpern and Robert Mitchell, gave it a name: the smartness mandate. Smartphones, smart homes, smart cities. Their book sums up the message that travels with every story about artificial intelligence: become smart or go extinct (Halpern & Mitchell, 2023).

The mandate doesn't ask whether you want in. It tells you the alternative is being left behind. Sign in with Google. Accept all cookies. Turn on location. Saying no sounds old-fashioned, like refusing to get a phone. The trap isn't in the technology. It's in the story about who uses it well.

It's an old story. Every tool that carried knowledge came with a gatekeeper and a warning. The medieval Church held the written word: accept its reading or be a heretic. England's Stationers' Company held the licence to print from 1557 to 1695: be licensed or be seditious (Patterson, 1968). Each hold loosened when the tools got cheap enough for ordinary people to own (Eisenstein, 1979), and each time the gatekeepers had called refusal backward.

Is it just Zuckerberg?

One man's tape proves nothing. But if refusing really were backward, those refusing would be those who understand technology least, and you can test that.

Every year, national statistics offices across Europe ask thousands of people how they handle their personal data online, and Eurostat publishes the results by job, education, age and income (Eurostat, 2025). So compare, country by country, the people who know the machine best with everyone else.

Europe, 2025 (internet users)IT professionalsOther professionals
Refused use of their data for advertising79%62%
Restricted access to their location78%59%
Blocked or limited cookies71%41%
Use anti-tracking software47%21%

The people who build and run these systems refuse them more, in 30 or 31 of 32 countries on each of those four counts. Graduates refuse more than people who left school early: on location, in all 36 countries. Young people refuse more than people over 65. In 2020, the best-off quarter of households refused advertising use more than the poorest quarter in all 27 countries with data.

Those are published group percentages, and skill, schooling, income and job all overlap, so the numbers show who refuses, not that skill causes it. But the direction holds almost everywhere. And knowing seems to come first. Four in five European internet users know cookies can track them, while only 35.7% have changed their settings. Countries where more people know have more people saying no.

A tax on not knowing

Now look at it from the bottom. The less you know about the machine, the less schooling you've had, the older and the poorer you are, the more of yourself you hand over. Researchers have a name for the shrug most people give: digital resignation, a feeling that nothing you do will make a difference, which companies help cultivate (Draper & Turow, 2019).

That shrug makes sense. You've got a job, kids and a phone that asks for decisions in grey text all week. But it means "become smart" doesn't describe the people who refuse. It describes what's asked of people who can't. Your nan pays the tax. The software engineer has already blocked the bill.

What one student did

You don't need to be an engineer to say no, though. Around 2011 Max Schrems, an Austrian law student, asked Facebook for the data it held on him. It sent back 1,222 pages (Legal Cheek, 2015). He filed complaints with the Irish regulator, and kept going for years. On 6 October 2015 the Court of Justice of the European Union struck down the Safe Harbor deal that let companies move Europeans' data to the United States (Court of Justice of the European Union, 2015). A student asked a question, and the answer changed the rules for an entire continent.

He had a good law to stand on, and that matters. European rules gave him the right to ask and a court to hear him. A refusal alone is a private act, and it mostly protects the person who knows how. Rights protect the rest.

Keep the tools, change who holds them

None of this means going back to paper. The same technology can be held by those who use it. A login made from a key you hold yourself. An AI model running on your own machine, not rented from a company's servers; open models of that size are free to download now (DeepSeek-AI, 2024). Phones that pass messages to each other over Bluetooth, so that the network is your neighbours.

The framing says smart means corporate, and holding it yourself means primitive. The people who know best already act as if that's wrong. So the mandate says become smart or go extinct, and the better answer is: become free. The technology's the same. The ownership isn't.

What you can do

You shouldn't need a computer science degree to keep your own life to yourself. Until the law catches up, here's the cheap version of what the experts do.

  1. Tonight, go into your phone's settings and turn location off for every app that doesn't need it. On each cookie banner, click "reject". It takes one more second, and now you know why they made it take one more second.
  2. Show someone. Sit down with your mum or the bloke next door and do theirs. Older Australians can also get free lessons through Be Connected, from the eSafety Commissioner.
  3. Ask a company what it holds on you. In Australia the Privacy Act gives you a right of access to your personal information from most larger businesses. Send one email and see how many pages come back.

Sources

  1. CNBC. (2016, June 22). Mark Zuckerberg tapes up his webcam. https://www.cnbc.com/2016/06/22/mark-zuckerberg-tapes-up-his-webcam.html
  2. Court of Justice of the European Union. (2015). Schrems v Data Protection Commissioner (Case C-362/14). https://curia.europa.eu/juris/liste.jsf?num=C-362/14
  3. DeepSeek-AI. (2024). DeepSeek-V3 technical report. arXiv. https://doi.org/10.48550/arXiv.2412.19437
  4. Draper, N. A., & Turow, J. (2019). The corporate cultivation of digital resignation. New Media & Society, 21(8), 1824–1839. https://doi.org/10.1177/1461444819833331
  5. Eisenstein, E. L. (1979). The printing press as an agent of change. Cambridge University Press. https://doi.org/10.1017/cbo9781107049963
  6. Eurostat. (2025). Privacy and protection of personal data (2020 onwards) [Data set isoc_cisci_prv20]. https://ec.europa.eu/eurostat/databrowser/view/isoc_cisci_prv20/default/table
  7. Halpern, O., & Mitchell, R. (2023). The smartness mandate. MIT Press. https://doi.org/10.7551/mitpress/14623.001.0001
  8. Legal Cheek. (2015, October). Vienna University's Max Schrems has created a piece of EU law in his spare time. https://www.legalcheek.com/2015/10/law-student-wins-landmark-privacy-case-against-facebook-and-is-congratulated-by-edward-snowden
  9. Patterson, L. R. (1968). Copyright in historical perspective. Vanderbilt University Press.

Keep reading