Would a zookeeper pass the way we live?
When a polar bear swam in figure eights, the zoo inspected his life. Scored the same way, the places people live and work fail on 17 of 18 measures.

Cover of The Human Enclosure (Omxus Press)

Photo: A. C. Applebee
In 2016, in a laboratory in Cork, researchers gave rats the gut bacteria of people with depression. The rats stopped enjoying sugar water. They grew anxious. Nothing had been done to their brains. So where is depression, exactly?
Peppermint Grove, Perth. You can stand in this on a perfect day and still feel nothing. Why?
This article is about depression. If it brings up something hard, Lifeline is on 13 11 14, any time.
The team at University College Cork recruited 34 people with major depression and 33 healthy people of similar age. They sequenced the bacteria in everyone's stool. The depressed group's gut held fewer kinds of bacteria. Then the researchers took samples from some of the patients and some of the healthy volunteers and transferred them into rats whose own gut bacteria had been cleared with antibiotics (Kelly et al., 2016).
The rats given depressed people's bacteria lost interest in a sweet drink they normally prefer, the animal version of losing pleasure in things. They behaved more anxiously. The chemistry of their blood changed too: more of the amino acid tryptophan, the raw material for serotonin, was being turned into something else. The rats given healthy people's bacteria did not change. A team in Chongqing, China, found the same thing in mice the same year (Zheng et al., 2016).
Something travelled from gut to gut, and arrived looking like a mood. Rats aren't people, and a rat can't tell you how it feels. But think about who this finding is for.
Picture a woman in a GP's office, a composite of many. She hasn't slept properly in months. Her joints ache. She describes a heaviness, not sadness exactly, more as if her body were made of concrete. She eats what she can afford, because the rent took everything else. She works 40 hours a week at a job that treats her like furniture, and she hasn't seen her friends in weeks. The GP writes a prescription and explains: your brain doesn't make enough serotonin.
For thirty years the public explanation of depression was simple: your brain does not make enough serotonin, and the pills fix it. In 2022 a team led by the psychiatrist Joanna Moncrieff gathered every major line of evidence for that idea. They found no consistent sign that depressed people have less serotonin activity than anyone else (Moncrieff et al., 2022). Other psychiatrists have disputed how far the review reaches, and the fight is still going.
That review did not say antidepressants never help, and nobody should stop a medication without their doctor. It said the reason we were given was not the reason. So what is going on?
When the body fights an infection or a wound, the immune system releases signalling proteins that make us tired, flat, withdrawn and watchful. Sickness behaviour kept injured animals still and safe (Miller & Raison, 2015). It is supposed to switch off. Chronic stress, isolation, broken sleep, sitting all day and a diet of ultra-processed food keep it switched on (Berk et al., 2013; Slavich & Irwin, 2014).
Across 37 studies of 13,541 depressed patients, about 27% carried high levels of C-reactive protein (above 3 mg/L), the standard blood marker of inflammation, and 58% were above 1 mg/L (Osimo et al., 2019). You can check that against a whole country. In the US national health survey of 2015 to 2018, which takes blood from a representative sample of 9,164 adults and asks them about their mood, 45.1% of adults with clinically significant depression had high inflammation, against 33.9% of adults without it. The more inflamed the blood, the more common depression became: 5.8% at the lowest level, 13.9% at the highest. High inflammation went with 1.53 times the odds of depression once age and sex were held equal, almost exactly the 1.46 found in clinical studies by other teams (Osimo et al., 2019).
Not every depressed person is inflamed. Grief, trauma and other causes are real. But for a large share, the low mood is the brain reading a body in a long, slow emergency, and reading it accurately.
The survey has limits. It is one snapshot, so it shows that depression and inflammation travel together, not which comes first, and the cycle probably runs both ways. Leave out the readings that may mean a passing infection and the figure is 36.6%. Add body weight to the sums and the odds ratio falls to 1.25 and loses statistical significance, but fat tissue makes inflammatory signals itself, so that adjustment removes part of the pathway, not only a rival explanation. The direction of cause rests on the rat and mouse transplants above, and on the infliximab trial below.
The inflammation has sources. Chronic stress, broken sleep, sitting all day, fat tissue, smoking and loneliness all feed it (Berk et al., 2013). So does ultra-processed food: common food emulsifiers thinned the protective mucus layer of the gut and promoted low-grade inflammation in mice (Chassaing et al., 2015). The people most likely to eat that way are the people who can least afford anything else.
If depression runs through the body, the body is also a way out. In Melbourne, Felice Jacka's team ran the SMILES trial: 67 adults with moderate to severe depression, half given seven sessions with a dietitian to move towards whole foods, half given friendly social support instead. After twelve weeks, 32.3% of the diet group were in remission, against 8.0% of the support group (Jacka et al., 2017).
Exercise works too. An overview of 97 reviews found physical activity eases depression with a moderate effect (Singh et al., 2023), and walking, yoga and strength training all helped in a large comparison of trials (Noetel et al., 2024). In a trial of an anti-inflammatory drug for hard-to-treat depression, the drug did nothing for most people, but patients with high inflammation at the start improved (Raison et al., 2013).
The serotonin story put the problem inside one brain and the fix inside one pill. The inflammation story puts it where people live: in cheap food made to be eaten fast, in work that leaves no time to cook or move or see friends, in sleep lost to worry about rent. Those are conditions, and conditions can change. Cheap food and pills are both good business, and nobody has to plan that for it to keep happening. That isn't a conspiracy. It's a supply chain.
Nobody should stop a medication without medical advice. Antidepressants help plenty of people, and they may be helping you. But a prescription needn't be the only tool.
If you're depressed, ask your GP whether your CRP has been measured. If it's high, ask what exercise, sleep and food could look like alongside anything else you're offered. Ask about seeing a dietitian: that's what the Melbourne trial did, and seven sessions was enough to show a change. Start small and don't punish yourself: a walk with someone, one real meal. On the worst days, getting up counts.
If it's someone you love, don't tell them to eat better. Turn up with soup and go for a walk with them.
Then ask the bigger question: who decided the cheapest food should be the food that inflames? Ask your MP why a family on a low income can afford the middle aisles and not the outside ones.
The woman in the GP's office isn't broken. For many people like her, the body is telling the truth. The question isn't what's wrong with her. It's what's wrong with the conditions that made her sick. If you need someone now, Lifeline is on 13 11 14, and Beyond Blue on 1300 22 4636.
The tree doesn't fix it. Neither does trying harder. Start with what's going on in the body.
When a polar bear swam in figure eights, the zoo inspected his life. Scored the same way, the places people live and work fail on 17 of 18 measures.

Cover of The Human Enclosure (Omxus Press)
In 2008 Denmark began paying night workers with breast cancer. Sleep advice still blames your habits. In a US sample, the job predicts who sleeps too little.

Cover of The Stolen Night (Omxus Press)
Twenty years of American time diaries show young people's time with friends fell from 137 minutes a day to 51, and the hours went to being alone.

Art: Omxus Press