What would it cost to fix the worst rule in Australian super insurance?
One definition in default disability cover refuses most people who claim on it. Using the regulator's own numbers, deleting it costs about six dollars a year.

Art: Omxus Press

Photo: A. C. Applebee
In 2010 a Spanish civil servant named Joaquín García was due a plaque for twenty years of service. Officials in Cádiz went looking for him and discovered he hadn't turned up to work for at least six years. Still on full pay, he'd spent the time reading and became an expert on Spinoza. Nobody had noticed. He denied it, and was fined €27,000 (Graeber, 2018).
Somebody's on the oval at sunset. Why isn't it you?
Most of us would laugh, and then go in tomorrow anyway. Work 22 hours. Keep your pay. Choose your hours. People hear that and call it utopian, lazy or impossible. So here's the sum: share the work Australia needs across every adult of working age, and it comes to about 22 hours a week each. That isn't a dream. It's division.
In 1930, with the world sliding into the Great Depression, the economist John Maynard Keynes wrote an essay for people who thought the good times were over. He called it "Economic Possibilities for our Grandchildren". Compound growth, he argued, would solve what he called the economic problem within a hundred years. His grandchildren would be four to eight times better off, and three hours of work a day, fifteen a week, would cover their needs (Keynes, 1930/2010).
He was right about the money. He was wrong about the time.
The Penn World Table, a dataset economists use to compare countries over decades, tracks output and hours worked back to 1950 (Feenstra et al., 2015). In Australia, each hour of work produced 3.46 times as much in 2019 as in 1950. Hours per worker fell from about 42 a week to 33.
Run that the other way. At 2019 productivity, the Australian living standard of 1950 takes 9.7 hours a week per worker. The living standard of 1970, takes 15.4. Keynes's fifteen hours arrived on schedule for anyone content to live as Australians did in 1970. Only about 18% of the gain since 1950 came back to workers as time. The rest went into more output and more work.
Across 24 rich countries with records back to 1950, the ones whose productivity grew fastest cut hours most. Across 45 countries since 1970, that link has gone: a country's productivity growth no longer says anything about whether its people get time back.
In 2013 the anthropologist David Graeber offered an answer in a short magazine essay that went round the world: we filled the time with work that even the people doing it think is pointless. He called them bullshit jobs, and later sorted them into five kinds (Graeber, 2018):
How many jobs fit? It depends how you ask. YouGov asked British workers in 2015 whether their job made "a meaningful contribution to the world"; 37% said no (Dahlgreen, 2015). A study of 100,000 workers in 47 countries found 8% sure their job was useless to society and another 17% unsure (Dur & van Lent, 2019). A quarter of the workforce not confident its work helps anyone is not a rounding error. Every study agrees on one thing: people who believe their work is useless are worse off for it.
Graeber's answer is that the incentives point the wrong way (Graeber, 2018). An executive's status and safety in a restructure rise with headcount, so the rational move is to hire people and find them tasks. Rules create compliance jobs, and compliance industries have a stake in more rules. And an old belief, that toil is virtue in itself, means nobody asks whether a job produces anything. Australia has its own version: hard yakka, you earn your keep. If you believe in hard work, this is for you. You're working nearly twice the hours the work needs, and the surplus isn't going to you or your family.
Automation can make it worse. A 2025 survey of 350 academics at 37 Australian universities found that centralising and automating administration made their burden heavier (Woelert et al., 2025). The machine didn't remove the work. It moved it onto the people the institution exists for.
A bullshit job is not a shit job. A shit job is unpleasant, low-paid and necessary: cleaning, aged care, rubbish collection. The worker knows it matters. A bullshit job is often well paid, respected and pointless, and the worker must pretend otherwise every day. Graeber called that spiritual violence. It maps onto what clinicians call moral injury: the harm of acting against your own values.
The care that doesn't get done is the sharpest cost. The Royal Commission into Aged Care Quality and Safety found systemic neglect and understaffing (Royal Commission into Aged Care Quality and Safety, 2021). Aged care, disability support and mental health cannot compete for staff with better-paid office work. The country pays millions to produce reports and cannot find people to care for its old. The shortage is not of people. It is of sense about where they go.
The Australian Bureau of Statistics counts the hours Australians actually work in every industry. In 2025 the total came to 460.1 million hours a week, worked by 14.91 million people averaging 30.9 hours each. There were 16.95 million people aged 18 to 64 (ABS, 2026a, 2026b).
Start with a rough count. Take the 8.8 million Australians in survival essentials, physical production and the scaffolding of a society (schools, research, government, maintenance). Value them at a full 40-hour week: 352 million hours. Share that across the 16 million adults of working age. It is 22 hours each, 28 with a 25% buffer for friction and absence. That is not a dream. It is division. The official hours then check it.
Now pick which work counts as needed. Be generous. Count farming, mining, factories, building, power, water, transport, hospitals, aged care, childcare, schools, universities, government, police, defence, repairs and cleaning. Then add every shop, every warehouse, every café, pub and hotel, sport, the arts, media, phones, internet and computing. Leave out only finance, insurance, real estate, professional services like law, accounting and consulting, office administration and labour hire, and gambling.
That generous list of needed work takes 387 million hours a week. Shared across every adult aged 18 to 64, it is 22.8 hours each. A strict list, only the work that keeps people alive and things built, gives 16.9. And if every hour worked in Australia today is necessary, sharing it across every adult still gives 27.1 hours, eleven fewer than the standard week.
| What counts as needed work | Hours per adult per week |
|---|---|
| Strict: survival, production, schools, government | 16.9 |
| Broad: plus shops, hospitality, culture, media | 22.8 |
| Generous: plus all finance and professional services | 25.2 |
| Every hour worked today | 27.1 |
(ABS Labour Account 2025, shared across adults aged 18 to 64)
Not every adult can work. True. Share the broad list only across the people already in jobs and it comes to 26 hours each. Still twelve fewer than 38.
A consultant can't become a nurse tomorrow. Also true. The sum describes the work a country needs, not a plan to move anyone by Monday. Shorter hours in essential work, and more people trained for it, close that gap over years.
It's all government waste. The numbers don't say so. Over the ten years to June 2025, public-sector jobs and private-sector jobs both grew 24.6%, well ahead of population growth of 15.9% (ABS, 2026a, 2026b). Pointless work isn't a public-sector specialty. Graeber found plenty of it in banks and corporations.
Between 2015 and 2019, Iceland's public sector cut the week to 35 or 36 hours for more than 2,500 workers, about 1% of its working population. Productivity and service held or improved, and wellbeing improved (Haraldsson & Kellam, 2021). In Britain in 2022, 61 companies tried a four-day week for six months; 56 kept it (Autonomy, 2023).
In 2020 and 2021 governments did something they had never done. They wrote down which work was essential, and sent everyone else home. The supermarkets stayed stocked, the hospitals stayed open and the power stayed on. Then we chose to forget what that list showed.
Graeber's own answer was income people can live on without pretending, so they can refuse pointless work. Those jobs would then have to become useful or disappear, and essential work would have to pay more. In the largest recent American trial, people given US$1,000 a month for three years worked one to two hours a week less and took more leisure (Vivalt et al., 2024). They didn't stop working. Aged care, childcare, disability support, teaching and mental health must pay enough to compete with the office, or the office keeps the people.
And then share the hours. A four-day week of 30 to 32 hours leaves a wide margin above 22 and has already held up. If that much sustains a civilisation, the rest of the week belongs to the people who work it: to raise their own children, look after their own elders and sit with their neighbours. Graeber died in 2020. He spent his working life trying to persuade us to work less.
Write down what you did last week, hour by hour, and mark what would have mattered had it not been done. Show one colleague. Then ask your boss what the 4 Day Week pilots showed, and whether your team could trial it for six months: 56 of 61 British companies kept it (Autonomy, 2023). And next time someone tells you they're flat out, ask them what would happen if they stopped for six years. Somewhere in Cádiz, Spinoza is well read.
The oval's still there at five o'clock. So should you be.
One definition in default disability cover refuses most people who claim on it. Using the regulator's own numbers, deleting it costs about six dollars a year.

Art: Omxus Press
In 1930 a cereal factory cut its day to six hours and the women who worked there called it freedom. The machines did the work. Who kept the time?

Photo: A. C. Applebee
Australian house prices tracked wages from 1870 to the mid-1990s. Then the link broke. It was never your avocado. The records have a date on them.

Cover of Economic Servitude (Omxus Press)