What would it cost to fix the worst rule in Australian super insurance?
One definition in default disability cover refuses most people who claim on it. Using the regulator's own numbers, deleting it costs about six dollars a year.

Art: Omxus Press

Art: Omxus Press
In the Smoky Mountains of North Carolina in the early 1990s, psychiatric researchers were sitting down each year with the same 1,420 children, a quarter of them Cherokee, asking how they were going. Then a casino opened on Cherokee land, and the tribe voted to share the money. Nobody had planned an experiment. What would happen to the kids?
The casino opened in 1996 on the land of the Eastern Band of Cherokee Indians, and every enrolled member began getting a share of the profits: $500 in the first year, rising to around $9,000 (Costello et al., 2010). So Jane Costello and her team on the Great Smoky Mountains Study had something no one could have arranged on purpose: the same children, the same interviews, and a payment that reached some families and not others (Costello et al., 2003).
The dividend moved 14% of the study families out of poverty. Before the casino, children in poor families had more psychiatric symptoms than children who had never been poor (4.28 and 4.38 against 2.75). After it, symptoms of behaviour problems among the children lifted out of poverty fell by 40%, to the never-poor level, while those of children who stayed poor did not move (Costello et al., 2003). A child whose family crossed the line stopped looking different from a child who had never been poor.
The effect sat in conduct and oppositional symptoms: the behaviour schools punish. As adults, fewer Cherokee than non-Cherokee participants had any psychiatric disorder (30.2% against 36.0%), particularly alcohol and cannabis disorders, and the youngest cohort, with the longest exposure, did best (Costello et al., 2010).
The same data showed that an extra $4,000 a year for the poorest households added a year of schooling by age 21 and cut the chance of committing a crime by 22% (minor offences at ages 16 and 17) (Akee et al., 2010). The income improved children's emotional and behavioural health and personality traits, most of all for those who started furthest behind, through better relationships with their parents (Akee et al., 2018).
The objection is simple: pay people to exist and they stop working. In 1982 the State of Alaska paid every resident who had lived there for a year the same amount, $1,000. It paid 470,897 people, without a means test, a work test or a form asking what the money was for (Alaska Department of Revenue, 2026). It has paid a dividend every year since. Alaska's labour force participation stayed above the US average in every one of those years, by 1.5 to 9.1 points.
Using a synthetic control, Jones and Marinescu (2022) found the dividend "had no effect on employment and increased part-time work by 1.8 percentage points (17 percent)". The public figures since say the same: in years when the dividend was bigger, Alaska's participation didn't fall against the rest of the US.
Randomised trials agree. Banerjee et al. (2017) re-analysed seven government cash programs in six countries on one specification and found no systematic effect on work.
The largest US trial paid 1,000 low-income adults in Illinois and Texas $1,000 a month for three years, against 2,000 controls paid $50 a month. Recipients were 2.3 percentage points less likely to be employed in survey data, and 4.2 points in pooled administrative and survey data; they worked 1.3 fewer hours a week. The authors describe "a moderate labor supply effect" (Vivalt et al., 2024).
Two things stand out. The transfer was large: $12,000 a year, twice Stockton's payment. And the response was small: about two in a hundred recipients worked less or stopped, while the rest kept going. It's a real effect, and people who say cash has no cost should read it. It still isn't the collapse the objection predicts.
In Kenya, GiveDirectly paid about $1,000 once to more than 10,500 households in 653 villages, a shock worth over 15% of local GDP. The researchers found large spillovers to neighbours and firms, "minimal price inflation", and a local multiplier of 2.5 (Egger et al., 2022). The money did not vanish into prices. It moved through the village.
It is spent on food, rent, utilities and transport, and less on alcohol and tobacco than before (Evans & Popova, 2017). In Stockton, California, 125 randomly selected residents got $500 a month. In the first year, full-time employment among recipients rose from 28% to 40%, a 12-point gain, against a 5-point gain (32% to 37%) among controls; the peer-reviewed analysis found the shift toward work pointed the same way without reaching statistical significance (West & Castro, 2023). Food was the largest spending category every month and less than 1% of tracked purchases were alcohol or tobacco (West et al., 2021). In the Namibian village of Otjivero-Omitara, a program report found child malnutrition fell from 42% to 10% (Basic Income Grant Coalition, 2009): from about four children in ten underweight to about one in ten.
Ontario enrolled about 4,000 low-income people in 2017. A newly elected provincial government cancelled the pilot in 2018, two years early, before the planned evaluation. Researchers studying the Hamilton participants found improvements across quality-of-life measures alongside "a small decline in labour market participation" (McDowell & Ferdosi, 2021). The evidence Ontario paid to collect was never finished.
Alaska's dividend has survived every government since 1982. The difference is design:
The Cherokee children grew up in households that could absorb a bad month. Their parents fought less. It wasn't that the money taught anyone anything. It took a weight off, and what was underneath turned out to be fine: children who behaved the way children do when the grown-ups aren't scared. One tribe in one valley can't settle it alone, and part of what lifted those families may be hard to separate from everything else that casino brought. But add Alaska, Kenya and Finland and the picture is hard to wave away.
So unconditional cash doesn't make most people stop working. It buys health, schooling and room to build something. The question left is political: whether a government builds it as Alaska did, universal, owned and funded to outlast the government that starts it, or as Ontario did, a pilot the next government could cancel before anyone read the results. That's a choice, not a finding.
Australia has minerals, and a Treasury review that said in 2010 the public should get more for them. Ask your federal MP why we don't have a fund that pays everyone a share, as Alaska does. When someone says "they'll just spend it on booze", tell them about the shopping records from Stockton: food first, and alcohol and tobacco under 1%.
And if you've got a bit of room in your own month, you don't have to wait for a government. Send the money straight to someone who needs it, with no questions and no conditions. GiveDirectly does it across the world, and in your own street you can just do it. It works for the same reason it worked in those mountains. A family that isn't frightened about money can pay attention to its kids.
One definition in default disability cover refuses most people who claim on it. Using the regulator's own numbers, deleting it costs about six dollars a year.

Art: Omxus Press
In 1930 a cereal factory cut its day to six hours and the women who worked there called it freedom. The machines did the work. Who kept the time?

Photo: A. C. Applebee
Australian house prices tracked wages from 1870 to the mid-1990s. Then the link broke. It was never your avocado. The records have a date on them.

Cover of Economic Servitude (Omxus Press)