In the autumn of 2016, interviewers with clipboards went door to door across Ireland, at addresses drawn at random, and asked people to help settle the bitterest argument in the country. Politicians had been dodging it for 35 years. What would 99 strangers do with it?
Choosing people for a public job by lot, not by election, is called
sortition. Athens ran on it for two centuries. This article looks at what happens when a
modern country tries it.
The knock on the door
In August 2016 the Irish government hired a polling company, Red C, to find 99 members of
the public and 99 substitutes. Its interviewers went door to door in 15 regions, at sampling
points drawn at random from the census, filling quotas for gender, age and social class. The
rules were strict: anyone chosen had to be on the register to vote in a referendum, nobody
who had campaigned on the topics could sit, nobody could apply, and an interviewer couldn't
recruit friends or family (Citizens' Assembly, n.d.-a).
So 99 people opened the door and said yes, for their expenses and nothing more (Farrell et al., 2019).
They met first at Dublin Castle on 15 October 2016, chaired by Mary Laffoy, a former
Supreme Court judge. Then came five weekends on the Eighth Amendment at the Grand Hotel in
Malahide, from November 2016 to April 2017 (Citizens' Assembly, n.d.-b). The public sent in
more than 13,000 submissions. Groups from every side presented, and lawyers, ethicists and
obstetricians advised (Farrell et al., 2019). They also heard from women the ban had affected directly. At the end, 79 of the 91 who voted said the constitution's ban shouldn't stay as it stood.
A question that had split Ireland for 35 years
The Eighth Amendment went into the constitution by referendum on 7 September 1983,
66.9% to 33.1%. It gave "the unborn" an equal right to life with the mother.
The assembly's recommendation went to a committee of parliament, and parliament then put
the question to voters. On 25 May 2018, 66.4% voted to repeal, on a turnout of 64% (Referendum Commission, 2018). The
lottery chose who deliberated. The vote was still everyone's.
Ireland had tried the method once before. Its Constitutional Convention, 66 randomly chosen
citizens sitting with 33 politicians from 2012 to 2014, recommended marriage equality, and the
country approved it 62% to 38% (Farrell et al., 2019).
| Year | Question | Who deliberated first | Referendum |
| 1983 | Add the Eighth Amendment | Nobody: a campaign and parliament |
Yes 66.9% |
| 2015 | Marriage equality | 66 citizens by lot, 33 politicians |
Yes 62.1% |
| 2018 | Repeal the Eighth Amendment | 99 citizens by lot |
Yes 66.4% |
| 2024 | Family and care wording | 99 citizens by lot, then rewritten by
government | No 67.7% and 73.9% |
(Electoral Commission, 2024; Referendum Commission, 2018)
A meitheal for a hard question
Irish has a word for this: meitheal, a team of neighbours who help each other in
turn with the harvest. Today it can mean friends who turn up to paint your house for food and
a drink. It carries the idea of neighbours answering each other's needs.
The assembly was a meitheal for a question. Put 99 neighbours in a room for five weekends,
give them the evidence and each other, and they bring in what politicians couldn't. A country
used to neighbours doing the hard work together trusted neighbours with this one.
Older than the ballot box
Athens filled its Council of 500 by lot each year, and chose juries of 501 citizens the
same way, using stone allotment machines called kleroteria. Offices lasted one year (Manin, 1997). Aristotle and other Greek
writers called lot the democratic method and elections oligarchic, because campaigns favour
whoever is already known or rich. Athens also kept out women, slaves and foreigners, so the idea has a long way to have come.
The OECD counts hundreds of citizens' assemblies chosen by lottery for public decisions, and
finds their use rising since 2010 (OECD, 2020).
Australia has done it too
In 2016 South Australia's Royal Commission raised the idea of storing other countries'
spent nuclear fuel for money. The state asked its people. The newDemocracy Foundation, a
non-profit, mailed invitations to 25,000 randomly chosen South Australians. A first jury of
about 50 read the 318-page report and chose what mattered. A second jury of about 350 met
over three weekends in Adelaide (newDemocracy Foundation, 2016, 2017).
Two-thirds voted not to pursue the plan "under any circumstances". Their main reason was a
lack of trust (newDemocracy Foundation, 2017). The proposal was
abandoned in 2017.
The jury didn't say what the government hoped to hear. That's the point: a jury that can
only agree is decoration.
Where it falls short
- It only advises. In 2024 the Irish government narrowed an assembly's
gender-equality proposals and split them into two questions. Voters rejected both (Electoral Commission, 2024).
- People drop out. Ireland's 99 lost members before the final vote, and had to replace them (Farrell et al., 2019).
- The lottery must be clean. In 2018 replacement members were
removed after it emerged they'd come through acquaintances of a polling employee, not by random
selection (Citizens' Assembly, n.d.-a).
- A room can still be pushed. In Adelaide about 30 jurors reported feeling
intimidated by an activist faction, only about four were Indigenous, and organisers said six
months was too short; two years would have been better (newDemocracy Foundation, 2017).
None of these is fatal. Each is a rule to write down before the next lottery is drawn.
What you can do
- Say yes. The invitation is the one time the system asks you, not your representative.
- Ask your council or state whether it has ever run a citizens' jury, and whether it
published what the government did with the answer.
- Next time a politician calls a question too hard, ask why it can't go to a jury, the way
Ireland sent its hardest one. Swiss voters decide more directly still; see
how Swiss direct democracy works.
Ninety-nine strangers helped settle what 35 years of campaigning couldn't. The method is 2,500
years old. It just needs someone to answer the door.