If your street in Porto Alegre had an open drain in the 1980s, you knew how the system worked. You found the neighbourhood leader who knew a councillor. The leader delivered votes at election time, and with luck a pipe arrived (Abers et al., 2018). Then the city changed the rule, and the drains moved to the top of the list.
Two cities in one
By 1991 one family in five in Porto Alegre lived in a vila, a poor settlement without land title or proper services. In the central region fewer than 2% of people did. In the northeast, 73% did (Abers et al., 2018). Brazil had only just come out of two decades of dictatorship, which hadn't asked these suburbs anything (World Bank, 2003).
Olívio Dutra's Workers' Party took the mayor's office in 1989 on about a third of the vote. It had two ideals and no clear model for either: make decisions radically more democratic, and turn spending towards the poor. Dutra's team spent the first year looking for a way (Abers et al., 2018).
What they found didn't look like much. The city would hold open meetings, and anyone could come. In 1990 under 1,000 people did (World Bank, 2003).
How a sewer got to the top of the list
Each year, residents met in their own neighbourhoods and regions and named what should come first: sewers, paving, housing, schools, health. They elected delegates, who turned those wishes into a list of actual works. A citywide council worked that into the investment budget, with the city's departments made to come and explain themselves (World Bank, 2003).
The clever part was the weighting. Money went by a formula combining what people voted for, how badly a region lacked the service, and how many lived there. So a suburb with open drains didn't have to out-shout a suburb with good lawyers. And it broke the old trade. Why promise a councillor your street's votes for a pipe, when the pipe gets decided in a hall you can walk into?
People saw the things they chose get built, and they came back with their neighbours. By 1996, over 14,000 came to the two rounds of assemblies. The poor came: in 1998, 30% of participants earned under twice the minimum wage, against 11% of the city. Neighbourhood associations doubled, from 300 to 600, and leaders who wouldn't bring their community along got replaced (Abers et al., 2018; World Bank, 2003).
What changed
| Measure | Before | After |
| Households with sewer connections | 46% (1989) | 85% (2002) |
| Households with water | 80% (1989) | 98% (1996) |
| Children in public schools | 1989 level | doubled by 1996 |
Between 1989 and 1996 the city laid 900 km of sewage lines and storm drains. Every government before it, put together, had laid 1,100 km. Revenue rose by nearly half, which the World Bank's note partly credits to people seeing where their tax went. The party's vote went from 34% to over 56% (Abers et al., 2018; World Bank, 2003).
A sewer sounds dull until you think about who it keeps alive. Researchers who followed Brazil's largest cities over about 20 years found participatory budgeting strongly linked to more health spending and fewer infant deaths, and the link grew the longer a city kept it running (Touchton & Wampler, 2014). That's a correlation, in cities that chose to try it. But if it's even partly right, some babies lived because their neighbours went to a meeting about drains.
It spread
Over 80 Brazilian cities had followed by 2003 (World Bank, 2003), and by 2018 more than 2,700 governments ran some version (Abers et al., 2018). In New York in 2024, 24 council districts put $24 million of capital spending to a public vote, open to anyone 11 or older who lived, worked or studied there (CityLand, 2024). Melbourne tried a cousin of the idea in 2014: 43 randomly chosen residents met over six weekends and wrote the council's 10-year financial plan, and the council accepted nearly all of it (newDemocracy Foundation, 2014, 2015).
How it faded at home
The Workers' Party lost the city in 2004. The new mayors kept the assemblies but gave them less. Under the old government more than 80% of the projects in the city's plans had been finished by the end of 2004. Of those approved from 2005 to 2016, almost 60% were still pending in early 2017. That March, a new mayor announced a two-year suspension (Abers et al., 2018).
Nobody needs to abolish a thing like this. Just stop building what people vote for.
It has other limits. The very poorest still came least, because meetings cost time and they had none (Abers et al., 2018). Copies elsewhere can shrink to a sliver of the budget and a click on a shortlist, nothing like a year of meetings. And it decided only investment, never wages or debt. Still, the assemblies didn't fail. They worked while the city gave them real money and did what they said.
What you can do
Life is hardest for people whose problems sit at the bottom of someone else's list. This moved the list.
- Find out whether your council sets aside any capital budget for residents to decide. If not, ask why not at the next budget consultation.
- If it does, ask whether the money leans towards the suburbs with least, or whether the loudest suburb wins.
- Ask what happened to last year's winners. Were they built? Porto Alegre's whole story turns on that question.
A council budget usually gets written by staff and passed by councillors, and residents find out when the roadworks start. Porto Alegre ran it the other way round for fifteen years. The people with open drains voted first, and the sewers followed.
Sources
- Abers, R., King, R., Votto, D., & Brandão, I. (2018, June 13). Porto Alegre: Participatory budgeting and the challenge of sustaining transformative change. World Resources Institute. https://www.wri.org/research/porto-alegre-participatory-budgeting-and-challenge-sustaining-transformative-change
- CityLand. (2024, April 8). City Council invites New Yorkers to vote for participatory budget projects through April 14th. https://www.citylandnyc.org/city-council-invites-new-yorkers-to-vote-for-participatory-budget-projects-through-april-14th/
- newDemocracy Foundation. (2014). City of Melbourne People's Panel. https://www.newdemocracy.com.au/2014/08/05/city-of-melbourne-people-s-panel/
- newDemocracy Foundation. (2015, June 29). The Age: Experiment pays off, Melbourne People's Panel produces quality policy. https://www.newdemocracy.com.au/2015/06/29/the-age-experiment-pays-off-melbourne-people-s-panel-produces-quality-policy/
- Touchton, M., & Wampler, B. (2014). Improving social well-being through new democratic institutions. Comparative Political Studies, 47(10), 1442–1469. https://doi.org/10.1177/0010414013512601
- World Bank. (2003). Case study 2 – Porto Alegre, Brazil: Participatory approaches in budgeting and public expenditure management (Social Development Note No. 71). worldbank.org